5 Insurance Policies You Don't Need

5 Insurance Policies You Don't Need

I was raised in a family that worshipped at the altar of insurance. If it costs more than $200, it better be covered by some form of insurance. Because what if it breaks? Or giant trolls break into the house and throw a kegger? But I don't think my parents realized how much money they flushed down the toilet by insuring everything not nailed down.

Pet Insurance. We were the typical nuclear family: two parents, two kids, two neurotic but lovable dogs. Our dogs were always insured growing up, but mine aren't. If you find a good local vet, and your pet is reasonably healthy, pet insurance is often a waste of money. Sure, he could develop a terrible disease that costs thousands of dollars in vet bills, but it's that kind of thinking that leads to insurance overkill.

Cancer Insurance. I don't think my parents bought this type of insurance, but it's growing increasingly popular. This is an example of fear-based insurance overkill wherein consumers buy a policy "just in case" and insurance companies rely on their customers' terror to sell the product. According to MSN, however, your regular health insurance should be sufficient to protect you if you are diagnosed with cancer, and the exclusions and requirements attached to this type of policy can render it not only redundant, but patently useless.

Collision Insurance. It drives my dad up the wall that I don't carry collision insurance on my six-year-old Mazda truck. But come on! Paying more than the vehicle is actually worth every couple of years is definitely insurance overkill, especially when the payout will not put much toward a new car should I get in a devastating accident.

Page 1 of 2

Comments (31):

Charles K. I've had pet insurance for the last four years, paying $15 a month. Over the life of my dog (assuming a 12-year life span) that's about $2,200 in premium payments over the life of my pet. Two years after we adopted her she broke her leg. Between a trip to the pet emergency room (it happened on a weekend), several trips to the vet and a cast, we spent just over $1,000. When it was all said and done, we got a check from the insurance company for $800 (our deductible was $200). I can't speak for other pet insurance companies, but the one we have is top notch. We got the policy to cover a catastrophic event where we would otherwise have had to put her down. I think it's short-sighted to make a blanket statement that pet insurance is a waste of money. To each his (or her) own. - 08/20/2011
Da F. A cheap vacation I agree no travel insurance. I was supposed to go on my honeymoon during the bad winter storms and we got 12 inches the night before. I was very happy I got travel insurance...I was only out the small deductible compared to the whole trip I agree with Jack C about LTC insurance...got to longtermcare.gov and see how much you will sacrafice your retirement if you dont plan accordingly - 08/17/2011
Domicella B. This guy needs a reality check. "Mutt" or " Street Cat" does not mean that you love your pets any less. Vet bills are high and having the insurance really helps. If my former "street cats" need medical assistance, they will receive the best medical help available thanks to pet insurance. I have had to pay large vet bills in the past and I sleep much better knowing that, in the future, I will never see a vet bill for fifteen hundred dollars on my visa card. - 07/28/2011
Cindy C. Oh my. I can tell you that I'm so grateful that I have cancer insurance. I was diagnosed 5 yrs ago with Leukemia. The insurance paid me several thousand dollars when I was first diagnosed, has repaid me for flying across the country for a 2nd opinion (& will pay for having to go out of town for treatment), and repays me for the visits to my oncologist. If I ever need chemo, it will cover that cost also. Yes, I have regular insurance, but it doesn't totally cover the things my cancer policy does, which also covers other dreaded diseases I've not covered here. Btw, I have Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia and I am living with it. I bought my cancer insurance in 1993. I almost dropped it. Boy am I so glad that I kept it. No collision insurance either? I'm glad you could afford for anything from a minor scratch to a total replacement of your car if you get in an accident. Me, no thanks, I'd rather pay the insurance. My policy costs less than you'd think and I cannot replace my car at a moments notice. I wish I had pet insurance. I will have to put my dog to sleep if any malady falls upon her. That's a terrible thing to think since she's been with me through the worst couple of years I've ever experienced. I cannot afford to take her to the vet right now. - 06/12/2011
Sss S. My ex died of colon cancer at age of 48. Get that insurance - 06/09/2011
Rob G. Mr Author (Steve), Your 100% right on all counts: If I don't own a pet, I don't need pet insurance. If I don't own a vehicle, I don't need collision insurance. If I don't travel, I don't need travel insurance. If I'm self-employed, I don't need unemployment insurance. If I plan on living forever cancer-free, I don't need cancer insurance. As an insurance professional for the past 25 years, I can say with certainty that you are a complete idiot. - 06/09/2011

© 2012 Man of the House, Barefoot Proximity, P&G Productions